Bay City grapevine
Back

Rails to nowhere
By John Sollman

 

BAY CITY Nov. 23, 2009 --- 1911 was a big year for Tillamook County. That was the year modern rail transportation arrived. The Pacific Railroad and Navigation Company, incorporated in October 1905, punched a rail line through the Coast Range and down the Salmonberry Canyon, ultimately meeting up with the other end of the line under construction from Tillamook northward through Bay City, Garibaldi, Rockaway Beach and Wheeler. The completed line initially offered Portlanders a scenic eight-hour trip to luxuriate on Oregon's magnificent beaches, a welcome alternative to suffering mal de mer aboard the Elmore or the Argo and braving the hazards of bar crossings at Astoria and Garibaldi.

Although Elmer E. Lytle figures prominently in the early railroad, the Southern Pacific and Union Pacific Railroads had considerable influence over the project. It was in the interest of these two railroads to keep James J. Hill's Great Northern Railroad from building a competing route in Western Oregon. Lytle's P. R. & N., nicknamed the "Punk, Rotten and Nasty," contracted with Dr. William Hawk to construct a hospital in Bay City to care for injured rail workers, a common practice in those days. Lytle also built a number of sawmills to provide the road with materials for ties, trestles and tunnels. The line boasted 13 tunnels and 35 bridges, grades of up to three percent and 15-degree curves, significant challenges for any railroad.

The first train from Portland arrived in Tillamook in October 1911, and soon tourists were flocking to the beach. A prime destination was the resort community of Bay Ocean, which required a trip by launch from Bay City to the resort across the bay.

But the original P. R. & N. was doomed to a short existence. Lytle, who built the line for $5 million, sold it to the Southern Pacific in 1915. But names made little difference. The presence of a railroad, any railroad, brought an economic boom to Tillamook County. Though the passenger business faded rapidly with the advent of the automobile and construction of rudimentary roadways, a burgeoning wood products industry quickly took up the slack.

Ultimately, Southern Pacific divested itself of its branch line operations, and the Port of Tillamook Bay Railroad was born. Until December 2007, the P. O. T. B. Railroad carried dimension lumber from sawmills in Tillamook to markets in Portland and the Willamette Valley. That operation was interrupted following the great storm of 1996, and again after the December storms of 2007, from which it has yet to recover. (Source: "Railroad," by George Abdil, Tillamook Headlight Herald, April 2, 1953, reprinted in "Tillamook History.")

Today, anyone traveling via State Route 6 will notice the steady flow of trucks belching diesel smoke, carrying Hampton Lumber products to the Valley, products formerly transported primarily by rail.

Today, in the face of our economic downturn, the federal government has ponied up stimulus dollars to do just about everything short of washing the dog. The idea, of course, is to invest in improving our transportation infrastructure, generating jobs in the process. Sadly, the number of jobs created remains shrouded in the swirling mists of bureaucratic miasma.

But the Port of Tillamook Bay Railroad offers an ideal stimulus project --- one which not only restores an important segment of the Oregon Coast's transportation infrastructure, but also creates abundant jobs in the process.

It has been demonstrated that goods can be hauled by rail for a fraction of what it costs to haul by motor transport. A gallon of diesel fuel in a diesel locomotive will haul more tonnage than a gallon of fuel in a truck.

Let's look at the safety aspect. Truck traffic over Tillamook County's highways has increased dramatically since the shutdown of the railroad. Obviously, there must be a means of moving Tillamook's cheese and lumber products to market. Doing so by truck causes greater wear and tear on the highways and, naturally, rising maintenance costs. If maintenance is deferred, the highways will deteriorate rapidly and present increased safety hazards for all who use them. Compounding the hazards from highway damage, the mere presence of large numbers of heavy trucks laboring up steep grades or careening downgrade presents safety issues.

Presently, rock is being trucked down from Washington to accomplish long-overdue repair to the north jetty. In a recent presentation to the Bay City Council, Kevin Greenwood, the new Garibaldi Port Director, said approximately 1,000 boulders are being trucked down from a quarry in Washington State. Only one massive boulder can be hauled in a single truck. That's one thousand truck trips to Barview, plus one thousand return trips for more boulders.

Just think. If this much rock could have been delivered by rail, the cost of transportation, and the production of greenhouse gases, would be lowered significantly. If Hampton Lumber products were moved by rail, the numbers of heavy trucks on the highway would be markedly reduced and motorist safety enhanced by a similar factor.

G.K. (Pat) Patterson of Garibaldi has argued for restoration of the railroad ever since it was washed out in 2007. Patterson points to many additional bonus factors the railroad could offer. It could provide local transportation during flood emergencies, lessening the economic impact of such events. This was done during the 1996 floods. Railcars could provide temporary refuge for survivors of an earthquake or other major disaster. The passenger equipment in Garibaldi, used by the Oregon Coast Scenic Railway, could serve this dual purpose.

Patterson points out in a letter to the Headlight Herald Nov. 18 that the Pacific Railroad and Navigation Company, Inc., a nonprofit corporation formed several years ago, is undertaking a campaign to repair and restore the Port of Tillamook Bay Railroad. He also states in his letter that, with the railroad restored, the Tillamook Bay Community College could offer a curriculum in rail transportation, including operation and maintenance of rail equipment.

There are other factors as well. The Oregon Coast Scenic Railway, owned by Scott and Kim Wickert, is restoring vintage steam locomotives and passenger equipment. The Wickerts had hoped to establish a rail restoration facility and rail museum in Tillamook. This would introduce a new industry and new jobs to Tillamook. The wood products industry here and elsewhere is in decline at the moment, owing to uncertain timber harvests.

There is another element to consider: Rail tourism. The Oregon Coast Scenic Railway is gradually building its inventory of cars to run on local tracks. Presently, the rail tours between Garibaldi and Rockaway Beach run only during the summer, but several dinner trains and other excursions are offered at other times of the year.

At one time, the Wickerts and Aaron Zorko, then operating their equipment under the aegis of the Port of Tillamook Bay Railroad, offered autumn foliage tours up the Salmonberry Canyon, impossible today.

The Oregon Coast Scenic Railway presently has one operating vintage steam logging locomotive, a Heisler, which once operated in Mill City, Oregon. A logging 2-4-4-2 mallet, a Skookum, is presently undergoing restoration in California and is expected to be in operation here within a year or two. All rail equipment must, of course, be trucked in.

Patterson has often spoken of tours from the Valley to the Coast and back, much like the early days. To do this, of course, would require that the track and roadbed be upgraded considerably. Presently, speeds are limited to 15 mph in most areas. To make tours over the Coast Range feasible, the track would need upgrading to allow speeds of 25 mph. But even if this is not done immediately, restoration of the line into Hillsboro would make it possible to bring in a greater variety of vintage rail equipment to support rail restoration and rail tourism.

Rail buffs will come from hundreds of miles away to see and experience operating vintage steam locomotives and rolling stock. It's endemic in the breed. Steam trains are a great attraction for families as well. When the word gets out that Tillamook County has a rail museum and steam excursions, the tourists will come in droves, and with them a big boost for our local economy.

Tillamook County needs to get behind its railroad. Repair and restoration of the line will bring jobs and dollars to the County. The economic possibilities flowing from a well-maintained rail transportation system are virtually limitless. All that is needed is some imagination and innovative thinking.

Think about it!

Back


 

Home | The Back Fence | Past Issues of Grapevine | Contact | Slug's Eye View | History | Links

Website design and maintenance: WEB